Professional Players
| 1927-29 | Frank Sillin | NFL Dayton Triangles |
| 1930 | Charlie Havens | NFL Frankford Yellowjackets |
| 1935 | Henry Benson | NFL Philadelphia Eagles |
| 1935-36 |
Bernie Kaplan |
NFL New York Giants '35-'36 |
| 1935-40 |
Bill Shepherd |
NFL Boston Redskins '35 Detroit Lions '35-'40 |
| 1936-37 |
Lou Kaplan |
AFL Brooklyn Tigers '36 Rochester Tigers '37 |
| 1938 | Lou Lassahn | NFL Pittsburgh Steelers |
| 1944 | Nick Campofreda | NFL Washington Redskins |
| 1947 | Mike Phillips | AAFC Baltimore Colts |
