The Captains (4-3) held an 18-1 advantage in shots and 17-3 edge in penalty corners, finding the backboard four times in the second half to break open a 1-0 game at halftime.
Erika Wawzyanick (Wantage, N.J./High Point Regional) made nine saves for the Green Terror (3-3) while Emma Stout stopped the only shot she faced at the other end.
Cybulski finished a Haylie Black feed at the 23:37 mark for a 1-0 advantage.
Nearly seven minutes into the second half, Anne Gehring doubled the lead before Cybulski stretched it to 3-0 just over a minute later.
Nicole Kuykendall tacked on a pair of goals to set the final margin.
McDaniel returns to action at Virginia Wesleyan on Sunday. Game time is 1 p.m.
Score by Period 1 2 - F
McDaniel (3-3) 0 0 - 0
No. 19 Christopher Newport (4-3) 1 4 - 5
C – Ashley Cybulski (Haylie Black), 23:37
C – Anne Gehring, 41:46
C – Cybulski (Taylor Harrell), 43:02
C – Nicole Kuykendall (Kylie Cale), 46:57
C – Kuykendall (Courtney Russ), 60:48
Shots: M 1, C 18. Penalty Corners: M 3, C 17. Saves: M 9 (Erika Wawzyanick); C 1 (Emma Stout).